Yes read the Mark Weir thread and actually I'd agree with the people who claim he was an accident waiting to happen. Although one does notice a difference in tone between that thread and this one:-
The difference being that the Cumbria thread highlighted that if someone had said something to Mark way before that night, things might have been different. Hopefully JP is reading this and when for example a 'marginal weather' or 'late in the day' callout comes along, he doesn't make any wrong decisions.
No one is questioning anyone's Captaincy etc, but we all know in this type of business that the hardest thing to day is no .... even if the child from an earlier post is trapped in a car.