I am certainly not breaking the law by asking if people want to come flying with me on the basis that we share the cost. There is NO profit in it for me other than experience, and i certainly dont advertise the flights. I also, only fly where my passengers want to fly, and I still pay at least an equal share myself.
The debate began when my friend's uncle ASKED me to take him flying so he could fly over his house and home town. I explained to him how much the plane would cost, but I would pay an equal share to help make it affordable. I asked my friend if he would like to come up again, but this time with his uncle and in a 4 seater. He agreed, and dont forget he had already been up with me before on a cost sharing basis, with no complaint. He cancelled the night before the flight because he said the weather wasnt going to be suitable. fair enough.
His uncle still wants me to take him flying over his house, despite his nephews comments and has no issue with paying an equal share. (He originally offered to pay the entire cost of the plane. I explained to him the limitations of my private license, and that it is beneficial for me to get the experience anyway).
I think it very fortunate if you are wealthy enough or in a position to take people up for nothing, I dearly wish I was. Unfortunately, that is not the case and the only way I can afford to fulfil this childhood ambition of mine is by sharing the costs. If this is morally unacceptable then perhaps I should except the fact that I cant afford it, and leave the joy of flight to the elite that can.