Originally Posted by
Lyman
You have never wanted to accept my pov, fine.
It's got nothing to do with who the POV comes from, all I ask is at least *some* evidence to back it up.
My purpose in the discussion was to move some people off of precipitous thinking.
To the best of my knowledge, very few folk on these threads ever did so - in fact none who stayed around to discuss things did. Even those who actively bemoan the quality of low-hour pilots today have seen it as a system-wide issue rather than pointing the finger at this particular crew. The BEA wrote up the factual evidence, were very clear about system-wide issues and also did not disparage the crew. Throwing random "what-if"s into the mix serves to harm credibility as far as I'm concerned.