PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF 447 Thread No. 9
View Single Post
Old 28th July 2012 | 21:36
  #805 (permalink)  
jcjeant
 
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,777
Likes: 0
From: Germany
Remember, you used ONE A320 SIMULATOR, not a A320.
Where is your official documentation stating that the A320 autotrim stops at 3 degrees ?
If I remember well .. the Perpignan case don't really show a stop at 3° for the auto trim
It was full nose up .. and was not returned (manually) when plane got in direct law
I can be wrong ...
EDITED :
Stalled AF447 did not switch to abnormal attitude law
There has been no indication that the aircraft switched into any other control law, other than alternate, during the accident - suggesting that auto-trim was available throughout the descent.
Failure to realise a need for manual re-trim was central to the loss of an Airbus A320 over the Mediterranean Sea about six months before the AF447 crash.
The auto-trim had adjusted the horizontal stabiliser fully nose-up but, during a flight envelope test involving near-stall, the aircraft switched control laws and inhibited the auto-trim.
Without manual re-trimming, the aircraft pitched up sharply as the crew applied maximum thrust. It stalled and the crew lost control.
In its conclusions over the accident the BEA highlighted the rarity of the need to trim manually, which created a "habit" of having auto-trim available made it "difficult to return to flying with manual trimming".
"One of the only circumstances in which a pilot can be confronted with the manual utilisation of the trim wheel is during simulator training," it said. "However, in this case, the exercises generally start in stabilised situations."
In the wake of the A320 accident, near Perpignan in November 2008, the BEA recommended that safety regulators and manufacturers work to improve training and techniques for approach-to-stall situations, to ensure control of an aircraft in the pitch axis.

Last edited by jcjeant; 28th July 2012 at 21:42.
jcjeant is offline