I'm not a pilot but I find it very interesting how many pilots called these guys idiots
I suggest that comment is quite unreasonable.
The problem of concern (relating to the chaps in the front at the time) involves consideration of their training (which then involves consideration of their employer's training programs and philosophies) and subsequent piloting skill set, as well as experience overall.
It is reasonable to presume that they were typical fellows with typical mental capabilities and survival instincts .. but certainly not idiots.
We are all at potential risk of failing if the conditions are too far out of our personal comfort zones .. indeed, as is observed periodically, the simulator can be used as an instrument of torture to overload any pilot to the point where he/she cannot cope and, hence, fails. Pointless exercise but it happens.