BEagle. Maybe you are correct. Maybe the AF crew was "pig$hit thicke". Maybe they should't have been there.............
But they were there; and now they and 225 other people are dead.
If this accident were as easy to understand as you want to believe, then anyone with like selection, training and background needs to be grounded immediately.
All of these AF447 threads have " jumped the shark", but that isn't grounds to close them. If you don't like it, stop reading.