Dozy,
- In the 727 case, the 3 guys were in agreement to pull.
- In the AF447 case, you did repeatedly mention that the PNF wanted the PF to go back down, didn’t you ?
Having the classic yoke, it would have been obvious to that PNF that the PF was applying the opposite input to what was needed.
Sidestick is a sure way to waste valuable information in a multi crew operation.