PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF 447 Thread No. 6
View Single Post
Old 7th September 2011 | 15:42
  #799 (permalink)  
RatherBeFlying
20 Anniversary
 
Joined: Sep 2001
: CPL
Posts: 2,782
Likes: 203
From: Toronto
A Camel is a Horse Designed by a Committee

And the Airbus control laws are designed by a committee of engineers over a period of several months.

I am sure that the engineers were thoroughly conscientious, but it definitely looks that the pilots did not know what airplane they were trying to fly -- well the word Alternate was pronounced, but there was no learned disquisition in the cockpit on the implications of Alt 2B, even though I am sure the committee of engineers spent several days talking it over.

Engineers and programmers can get a bit carried away with themselves when getting into recondite corners -- here we see a proliferation of flight laws and a crew unprepared for Alt 2B combined with UAS at high altitude.

Applying KISS retroactively, the pilots would have known what airplane they were flying if Normal Law was flown with a touch pad and the stick, rudders and trim wheel were reserved for Direct Law

In a previous thread I mentioned that the VSI and altitude displays did not alert the crew to the descent rate problem until the 10,000' digit dropped off the altitude readout -- i.e. the readout went from 5 digits to four. Only at that time did the crew verbalise the altitude.
RatherBeFlying is offline