When and if we become aware of just what the crew knew and exactly when they knew it, then perhaps some of the above conclusions will be vindicated and some will be repudiated. Until then, my own opinion as to the propriety of this crew's actions under the conditions specific to this occurrence will remain open to revision pending the receipt of additional facts.
I just fail to see the logic in either condemning or supporting what was done without knowing what facts were available to the crew at the time of the occurrence or at any time during the flight thereafter.