Gentlemen,
I have read EVERY post here regarding AF 447. I remember June 2009 like it was yesterday. I am not a pilot. The intelligence and opinions here have been beyond enlightening. From takata believing the plane turned around (which it did but under different circumstances) to spot on weather examinations......all class work.
Unfortunately there are facts and the facts involved with AF 447 are disturbing. A STALL is a STALL. The plane was telling them that, the altitude was telling them that, buffeting was telling them that. OK... I get it...the pitots were clogged..there is confusion....the plane is confused....the pilots are confused. I hate to say it but the people on the flight deck were...morons. I know, it is terrible to say. How can a skilled aviator, make that 2, not know he is in a stalled position? We are talking about life and death and that is serious business. People are dead because 2 guys refused to acknowledge there was a problem.
What more is there to argue?