Superpilot - an unfortunate outbreak of rhetoric with absolutely no foundation of truth to it. You are, of course, entitled to believe that BALPA should disband and something new should replace it. That would undoubtedly please the folk like yourself with, what could most generously be called, a limited view of reality. If you think that a new union is going to defeat p2f, which incidentally is such a misused term that few people have any real understanding of what it means, then you will be sadly mistaken. So when the 'new' Union comes to town, don't forget to tell your mates all about it and then tell us exactly what they would do differently from the BALPA of the past.