For the record, Mr. Sinclair is not a judge. He was the Chair of the Tribunal, and he was a law professor, but he never was a judge.
In any event, his error in dismissing the complaints is about to be corrected without a judicial review. Air Canada agreed that the Tribunal should continue to hear the Charter arguments in the case, and the Tribunal has now ordered all parties to make submissions regarding the type of hearing needed to continue the case.