Victor, I am not trackin. The senior F/O
was Flying. Not clear why it is in any way beneficial that a "CRM issue be
avoided"?
So, by experience do you mean Time on Type? Or flying experience?
Colgan shows us a Captain with more flight hours than F/O but with substantially fewer ToT. Since it is believed he may have been recovering from a STALL other than mainplane (by mistake), perhaps she (FO) was better qualified to handle his emergency? (Self inflicted?)
