PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF447 wreckage found
View Single Post
Old 4th Aug 2011, 00:43
  #2541 (permalink)  
JJFFC
 
Join Date: May 2011
Location: PARIS
Age: 62
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
@ JcJeant

I believe that the stall warning has nothing to do with the mental problem of the PF : whatever the stall warning, the PF wanted to nose up and didn't understood why the PNF and the Capt asked him not to.

Abstract :

2 h 13 min 40
PF : But I’ve been at maxi nose-up for a while
Capt : No no no don’t climb
PNF : So go down


2 h 13 min 45
PNF : So give me the controls the controls to me
PF : Go ahead you have the controls we are still in TOGA eh

2 h 14 min 05 4,024 The pitch attitude is 14°.
Capt : Watch out you’re pitching up there
PNF : I’m pitching up?
PF : Well we need to we are at four thousand feet

(My) Conclusion:

The Capt. didn't knew how much the PF was nosing up but knew he shouldh't have.

The PNF knew he had to nose down but his fear prevented him from a strong forward stick;

The PF has alway wanted to nose up except when asked by the PNF or the Captain not to do.

The actions of the PF have been unbelievable / misunderstood by PNF and the Captain.

Not only the PF has created the stall by a stupid nose up but he has commited "a crime" when at 02:11:39 he took the controll back from the PNF without annoucement and continued to nose up against PNF and Capt.
JJFFC is offline