Most of us seem to agree that unstabilised approaches and long landings are a no no. If the exercise cannot be reasonably carried out due to the limitations of the sim then the checker is on shaky ground. Put it this way if your upgrade was delayed by at least a year because of this you might feel aggrieved. After all not being able to get down off a circle to land might also be construed as a fail. We have certainly asked people to come back for not being able to complete one. It is an interesting one. What is your opinion Centaurus?