I'd opt for a stick every time
So would I, but I think IO was referring the the
side stick, which is I think only found in Cirrus and the Corvalis (in aircraft of that particular market sector). I find flying our PA 28 - 180 quite tiring long distance as holding the yoke in the left hand with the grip needed results what for me is an odd angle and an aching shoulder! So yes, a conventional stick is far more comfortable.