Honestly, my picture of the accident includes everything I read here. I don't reject anything, you may notice my input has to do with proposing some things, some perhaps a bit bizarre, but what about this accident is NOT unusual? I do intend to embrace the Truth when it arrives, my perspective may not project that, but questions cause thought, unless rejected, and I think that is too bad.
This thread exemplifies what I think is a solid plus in analysis. There is no boardroom with a coffee maker and sandwiches which instill a faux civil atmosphere. It is a rare pilot who can be scrupulously objective. There are plenty here, and I admire all the people who post here.
As of now, it looks rather bad for the pilots, all three. I cannot figure out why in the world BEA would accede to pressure to release such an unsatisfying Note. It has made the adversarial nature of the discussion ever more polarized, not that it has any relevance on their Report.