The total experience level was actually quite low in this cockpit.
With lots of time on a specific type one tends to recognize what feels "right", "not right" or what can probably be disregarded. But rejecting after Vr? Someone has seriously not understood the concepts of a balanced take-off or V1. "Decision" being the keyword.
Someone will now come along and claim that 3000 hours is a lot.
Don't embarrass yourself.