PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF447 Thread No. 3
View Single Post
Old 7th June 2011 | 06:13
  #1534 (permalink)  
A33Zab
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 451
Likes: 0
From: somewhere
Normal airliner?

GB:

Quote:
What you are suggesting is an interconnection with both SS (Bus bar or by Electric synchronisation) and in abnormal situations you want to disconnect this synch.

A lot of engineering ahead for a feature which will be of -no use- most of the time.
The same could be said for Stall Warning and a lot of other basic items that are required by regulation on a normal airliner.

Quote:
There is a visual indication of resultant SS inputs on PFD on ground.
Lotta' good that does at FL 350.

The yoke in your gut on a normal airliner tells you the other pilot is pulling hard. You don't have to look at a display or at his hand, or a Trim in Motion alert. Does the A330 have a Trim in Motion alert?
Normal airliner?

-Visuals make no sense on FL350 but does when - normally - needed the most.

-As engineer i'm an outsider but do you really have eye in what the PF is doing with his yoke in such a mayham? Don't you have your own role by then?
Maybe you are right and they had better installed a yoke to become a normal airliner, but that doesn't change the FBW philosophy and in fact B is or will be as much flown by wire than A.

-Trim in motion alert: only visual for as I know....and that will be a proper enhancement: to make it audible too.
A33Zab is offline