Folks
May I point you to this
Spiegel online article with the following
The BEA report, in its current form, only provides the angle of the stabilizer but provides no explanation as to why. The report merely indicates that it was at this moment that Captain Marc Dubois re-entered the cockpit.
Exactly what orders he issued are not part of last Friday's report. But sources close to the investigation are saying that he said: "This is a stall. Reduce power and nose down!"
I have no idea about the veracity of this quote but I would tend to say that this is generally a serious publication. If confirmed this would obviously paint a very different picture.