I don't actually think the Le Figaro reply is of any value and worthy of any attention. I did post that human beings do strange and unaccountable things but I am not prepared to assign blame or responsibility for this incident to the flight deck crew based on what has come out. I am also happy to trust BEAs conclusions - I do not buy any of the rubbish posted about bias, it is just that rubbish. BEA has always been a reliable entity on accident reporting and anyone who believes otherwise is a fool (and no I have absolutely no connection with BEA). When I was young I was taught that patience is a virtue and this is something I continue to believe. Let us wait shall we?