I was always under the impression that the mark of a good pilot was "one who used superior judgement to avoid having to demonstrate superior ability".
It is my guess that neither guy will take any pride from recieving this award and both wish that they not put themselves in the position to qualify for it.
They cocked up no matter which way you try and look at it. Wannabes should stop being romantic and realise what is entailed in being a PROFESSIONAL PILOT.