PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF 447 Search to resume
View Single Post
Old 1st Dec 2010, 03:23
  #2513 (permalink)  
cpp6f
 
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: US
Age: 42
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
How did lack of airspeed data cause AF-447 to enter an unrecoverable stall?

The most likely theory for the crash at this time seems to be that the aircraft entered a violent storm, the pitot tubes froze over, and the pilots stalled the aircraft b/c they didn't have reliable airspeed data. I don't really understand why a lack of airspeed data could lead to a stall. I fly hang gliders and have no indication of my airspeed, yet I can still keep it from stalling - because I know that if I shift the CG back to a certain point it will stall so I never exceed this position. Now, I'm sure the handling of an A-330 is very different from a hang glider, but why do you need reliable airspeed data to keep from stalling? To my understanding, a stall occurs when the AoA exceeds a critical value causing boundary layer separation on the top surface of the wing and loss of lift. And as far as I know, AoA is controlled solely by the trim of the horizontal stabilizer. And a sensible pilot or flight computer would not trim the aircraft past the critical AoA. I see how a powerful updraft or tail wind could cause the wing to stall before the attitude can adjust, but couldn't that happen regardless of whether you know your airspeed or not?
cpp6f is offline