PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Widow criticises medical screening of pilots
Old 29th Nov 2010, 10:36
  #5 (permalink)  
EuroPPL
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Middle marker
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
The fact is that almost no automobile drivers are incapacitated by sudden cardiovascular incidents, even though they are not screened for cardiovascular health before being given a license. And conversely, there are still pilots who have sudden strokes and heart attacks, despite a more rigorous screening for pilot medicals. Which in turn implies that (1) medical incapacitation is extremely rare even in the general, unscreened population, and (2) screening people for heart disease won't necessarily reduce the already low incidence of incapacitation. The tests that might actually be able to verify if someone is at risk of incapacitation, at least in the case of cardiovascular disease, are extremely expensive and invasive, and thus not really practical. And the tests actually being used aren't really very reliable for isolating who will or will not be incapacitated.
(1) The obvious difference is that a car driver can easily and quickly stop the car and phone for help.
(2) It is possible to measure the diameter of arteries non-invasively, so this condition would have been detectable with a more complete test.
EuroPPL is offline