Leon,
Yes because the validity of an opinion is gauged by its popularity!!
Jindabyne,
Explain to me what future vulnerabilities to the defence of the UK will be countered by a Royal Navy consisting of 2 CVBGs and 4 SSBNs?
The justification for the CVs was organic AD for operations without HNS. With no ability to conduct opposed landings once the phibs are gone how are the troops going to get their? Are we planning on invading France via the Chunnel or are we only going to invade places served by Easyjet or Ryanair?
Carriers are a great idea as part of a balanced force structure. Sadly, we are not getting that because we cannot afford it.
Cheers
BHR
p.s. what was the last UK only operation that had no access to HNS for AD? Talk about preparing to fight the last war!! More like fighting one 4 or 5 back!!!