PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Equal Time point with off route Alternates - How?
Old 15th Oct 2010, 08:46
  #4 (permalink)  
Checkboard
 
Join Date: Aug 1998
Location: Ex-pat Aussie in the UK
Posts: 5,810
Received 134 Likes on 66 Posts
If you are trying to 'fag packet' it, good luck!
... or you could follow some of my methods below

Some methods for calculating inflight Critical Points (CPs)/Points of No Return (PNRs) (for on-track work) and Equi-Time Points (ETPs) and Last Points of Safe Diversion (LPSDs) (for off-track work) that are reasonably cockpit friendly:

ETP: By hand, the old fashioned way

Take your map (that piece of paper that hides at the bottom of your nav bag, under last month's Playboy ®) and fold it so that the two airports you are considering are placed directly on top of each other. Crease the fold line between the two airports and open up the map.

The crease line is the perpendicular bisector between the two airports. (I made that term up , it means that it is half-way between the airports, and at right angles to them)

Any point on this line forms an isosceles triangle with the two airports, (An isosceles triangle is any triangle having two equal sides.) and is a nil wind ETP. Of course the point we are interested in is the place where the crease line crosses our track. This all takes about two seconds to do.

How to adjust for wind? Mark your point on track at the nil wind ETP, then eye ball the wind vector. Consider the effect that the wind will have flying to each airport (i.e. if it is all cross-wind to ariport 'A' but all head wind to airport 'B', then you will have to slide the ETP along track so as to make the flight to 'B' shorter than that to 'A') Make a quick [distance/ground speed] check for each leg, and adjust if the times are a bit out. I can usually find the actual ETP in about 60 seconds this way.

Want to be more accurate? (Hold on for the maths bit ). Find the nil-wind ETP as above, calculate the time to either airport, nil-wind. Multiply that time by the wind (ie a nil-wind time of an hour and a half, a forcast wind of 30 knots = 45 nm 'adjusted' wind vector.) Now draw the adjusted wind vector on the map, so that the head of the vector is where the crease line crosses the half way point between the two airports under consideration (the nil-wind ETP).

Project the vector onto the line between the two ariports. (ouch! what does that mean?) It means take the cosine of the angle between the wind vector and the track between the two airports and multiply it by the length of the vector. (phew!) Not following - forget it then, you don't need to do this and you really need to be comfortable with trigonometry for this method. Now move the "perpendicular bisector" point along the line between the two airports the same distance as the projection, and draw a new "crease" up to your track - this is a pretty good approximation, within a couple of miles, of the actual ETP. (that's right, after all THAT it's only an approximation, which is why I said to "forget it" before )

To adjust further you will need to go into trial and error adjustments, and that is actually just about as fast if you didn't (want to) follow the trig stuff above. I can usually get an actual ETP in about 2 minutes (by which time the aircraft has travelled further than the adjustment! )

ETP: By FMC, a newer fashioned way

The fastest way I know is to use the GPS/FMS in the cockpit. You can even include this point in the GPS flight plan, and have the GPS tell you when you have passed it.

You can't fold the electronic map display ion the flight deck, so use the fix page to place a fix at each airport you are interested in. Draw a circle around each airport big enough to overlap each other (both circles must be the smae size). The two points of overlap form two points on the perpendicular bisector line - the crease in the map - above. With a bit of trial and error, you can adjust the size of the circles until the intersection is over your track, then pick up that point (the nil wind ETP) on the fix page, and place it into your flight plan at the appropriate point. You can then temporarily place each airport in turn after that ETP point to check the time to each airport - and if necessary adjust the point back and forth along track until the times are exactly the same (i.e. using the FMC to calculate adjustments for wind effect)

So what's the big deal about ETPs? Well, with the map thingy (takes about two seconds remember) you get a fast approximation, and sometimes (vary rarely) you need to work fast. Also if you have planned enough fuel to your destination then the LPSD is always PAST the ETP, if one of the airports being considered for the ETP is your destination, of course. So you also get an idea of where your LPSD is, or at least how much time you have to calculate it.

LPSD: Last point of safe diversion to an off-track airport

Calculate the fuel available for the LPSD. (i.e. Fuel on board minus fixed reserve minus holding minus variable reserve (÷1.1 for 10%, ÷1.05 for 5%) minus approach allowance)

Calculate the fuel required to fly all the way to the destination (in the configuration you are considering) then to the diversion you are considering.

Now:

[Fuel available for LPSD] ÷ [total fuel required] = [dist to LPSD] ÷ [distance to destination.] (Well... almost! ).

This means that the distance along track to your diversion point is roughly the same percentage of the total distance as the percentage of fuel available is compared to the fuel required to fly all the way to the destination and then divert.

So divide fuel available by the fuel required, then multiply that by the distance to your destination. This will give you an approximate (within 5%) distance to the LPSD.

To correct it plot this position, calculate the actual fuel to LPSD, then to diversion and compare it to the fuel available. If it is a little high (how many miles will this XS fuel require?), move the LPSD towards you enough to reduce the total track miles by an amount that would save the XS fuel, and check (or vice vesa). I can find the actual LPSD in about 90 seconds this way. Including this point in the GPS plan will have the GPS tell you when you have passed it.

As an aside:

For you piston guys, in the Australian regs there used to be a requirement for twin aircraft to ensure that they have enough fuel to fly (on two engines) to the single engine CP and then fly one engine out to an airport.
I don't know off the top of my head if this requirement survived the "just don't run out of fuel - OK?" changes where the CAA decided to get fuel reserves etc included in Company Ops manuals (of which maybe 10% have been ammended after 5 odd years, I bet...) however as most pilots learnt CPs at CPL stage, and that was, pehaps, two - three years before they really started flying twins, I bet that hardly anybody does this.

Of course the whole situation is not helped by the manufacturer's manuals, very few of which (especially Piper's) give any numbers for single engine cruise, but that's another whinge...

So, time for a "Rule of Thumb"

When a piston twin loses an engine, it has to slow form its normal cruise speed (with lots of parasite drag) to close to the long range speed. You will find that the aircraft is flying more efficiently on one motor at the single engine cruise speed, than on two at normal cruise! (but not as efficiently as on two at long range cruise, due to the added drag of the engine out thing.)

So the aircraft will fly furthur (through the air) one one engine than on two! Doesn't work for turbines, as they are forced to operate at a (inefficient) lower altitude.

So, the rule of thumb? If the headwind is less than 25% of the single engine cruise speed, planning normal ops fuel will also cover the engine out case.

So now you can say to the CASA guys when they jump out from behind the fuel bowser - yeah, I planned for that, and proceded to baffle them with the above!
Checkboard is offline