Fair enough Griz. I understand where you are coming from. I am not trying to argue how the injuries occurred - I obviously can't know. However I am trying to point out that we can't conclude anything on the basis of the information released into the public domain.
With the now very unlikely recovery of the recorders, after endless speculation about what the ACARS messages may or may not mean, and after 15 months of continuous debating various hypotheses, we are left with the conclusion that no one will ever no for sure what happened to AF447. And so we have to accept that in 2009, a modern aircraft can simply cease to exist - along with 228 people.
To me, the human factors analysis is the most helpful lead. Why did no one get a life jacket? Is there a reason why we have so many bodies and so little else? And what do the injuries suggest is most likely to have happened?
In pathology there is an old saying:.
Mortui Vivos Docent -The Dead teach the Living
Without wishing to offend anyone here, I suspect there are lessons to be learned. I just hope they have been.