Saturn, you really must calm down, Your blood pressure will make interesting reading, I'm sure.
Regarding the DFO's success and measuring it, one must first adopt a stance.
Look at it from the other side of the fence for a moment....
Everyone on B-scales (or less by mid 2014)
Freighter fleet integration back to main line
Frieghter Captains now flying pax.
Resolution (one way or another) of the 49ers debacle (remember he wasn't DFO at the time.
One paltry payrise since 2001
The list is much longer than this...
But before you write him off as a failure look at it from their point of view. I think you'll find that he is considered a success of sorts.
Additionally, just because he's been "D-cat'd" doesn't make him useless at his job, it just means that he won't be progressing any further. We have many pilots in the same boat!
Now on another (but related note), would you rather get shafted by a Swire Prince?....... Or a pilot? At least the Swire Prince is doing his primary job!!!