This thread is concerned with the Cabin Crew strike at BA and not with the perceived skills of pilots at BA.
The wonderful thing about your perceptions is that they are your own, and personal and cannot be argued with. That said, it is wise to consider carefully before posting. The 'analysis' above of the two landings is subjective and based on faulty assumptions, a shortage of knowledge and a failure to understand what knowledge exists. The only indisputable fact is that the writer was alarmed.
Some research on posts in this, and other forums on PPRuNe will reveal the accepted position that a seat in the cabin and a degree of previous experience of flying as a passenger are not the appropriate criteria for judging the quality of a landing - or indeed any technical aspect of a flight.