A lot of emotional, over the top comments here. Fact is,
1) We don't know who was at controls.
2) We don't know why the aeroplane crashed.
3) We don't know what effect anybody's type experience had or could have had.
In short, we certainly don't know enough to start a slanging match.
Even now it seems that the pilots of the Swiss scene are at each other's throats, when they need each others'good will more than ever. This will not help, gentlemen.
As others have mentioned it is also unethical and callous to criticise a colleague at this time.