PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - In-depth pictorial expose with analysis on the New Russian Fighter
Old 7th Jul 2010, 20:11
  #30 (permalink)  
The B Word
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Uranus
Posts: 960
Received 11 Likes on 9 Posts
As you know the T-45 eventually won in a fly-off against the Alphajet (a twin)
...nothing to do with the BAE partnering with McDonnell-Douglas then? Especially, when Dassault-Dornier had no US partnering agreement?

Come on John, there are many more reasons why the Hawk was chosen over the Alpha Jet than the "1 engine vs 2 engine" debate.

The fact that both donks failed on the aircraft that you mentioned does not negate the fact that many a twin-engine aircraft has returned on 1 donk safely - Hawk, Harrier and A4 drivers would have definately had to step over the side, if this had happened to them (excluding dead-stick)!

Nope, single engined jets have no "insurance" compared to multi-engined jets. What's even dumber about the JSF STOVL version is that it carries a perfectly serviceable 2nd engine pointing in the wrong direction (ie. the lift fan) - now that is dumb!

The B Word

PS I always thought that the first Tornado loss was P.08 in June 1979 and it was a CFIT oversea in the Irish Sea?
The B Word is offline