Capt Piche
Having known, trained and flown with capt. Piche several years before the incident, I can only say that he was an above average pilot. After being layed off, with family responsibilities, he did what most people would judge as irresponsible. Let us not sit here and judge what he did prior to the engine failure but praise the results and how the crew performed.
Those who have not tasted adrenalin during an emergency should refrain from any comment. We certainly can't predict our reactions, or performance. Have a good look at the tapes after you complete your LOFT training and CRM. Possibly your opinions will change.
As someone once quoted: IF ALL THE TIME YOU USE THINKING YOUR RIGHT....IS THERE ANY TIME LEFT TO THINK YOU MAY BE WRONG........