DHPilot
The personal grief issue has been addressed previously, again I point out no-one has brought this young mans training, culture or professionalism into question.
He did take a chance and it did turn out to be a mistake, the end result says so.
This exact event has occurred many times before and will continue to occur, simply because what he did is exactly what most of us here would have done. That's why it is very important to sit back in the comfort of our armchairs and pontificate as you put it.
As it has been said before, the accident report will not provide you with the answers you seek.
Read back through the entire thread and you will understand.