Bearfoil;
This looks definitely like a different spoiler than the one in the sea (your image
post #1253).
All the photographs in
post #1253 and
post #1290, including that in the BEA's Interim Report are all of the same spoiler. Check all the pics carefully and the damage and tell-tale marks all match.
Other than the BEA photograph, all the other images were supplied directly to me from the ship which picked the spoiler up. My only problem is establishing exactly what spoiler it is, as my initial impression was that it was the Starboard Outer, and I had recorded that in some graphics posted to the AF447 thread many moons ago. The BEA have since confused the issue with their caption.
mm43