PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Polish Presidential Flight Crash Thread
View Single Post
Old 30th May 2010, 21:37
  #147 (permalink)  
Alice025
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: St. Petersburg
Posts: 270
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Amelin's chart must be equal to TAWS chart (he presumes).
TAWS is from that shuttle flight record in year 2000.

But! Shuttle covered the area in question - but it doesn't mean the project people spent the two following years fine-tuning the resulting terrain map, as they did with other places and airports. Cleaned "errors", adjusted, how to say, it follows they did a lot of work to make it a TAWS usable map, from the data of the Shuttle flight, worked on it, for a long time.
Because Smolensk Northern airport in particular - is not in TAWS database.

So TAWS data re Smolensk may be an approximation, and not to be taken for guidance for automated approach. I mean, it's not for nothing this aerodrome is not officially in the TAWS system - means, they don't guarantee the exactness, simply, has not thought it'll be of use to anybody, when were working on the data.

I think it can be like this.

And I think as the Russian-Polish commission did fly to TAWS makers "to help clarify some details" - may be this is what they were clarifying.
In particular - also - which map of heights is correct - the MAK or the TAWS idea of it.
I think Poles also wanted to know what to use as a base, is MAK map trust-able.

They don't tell us any thing! One has to extrapolate, which questions they had to TAWS. And which answers they've got from the makers. Can be about the map.
Alice025 is offline