Just thought I'd add my two penneth here.
For a lot of people check lists provide a feeling of security. For the irregular flyer they assist in not over looking a check.
Do I use them? NO
I agree with QDM that checklists in light singles remove the 'thinking and understanding' behind what is going on. As an instructor I find many students run through the list without really 'checking' at all. It is scary at first to fly without a list but if you have been taught how to monitor and scan the panel in a reliable and logical way then there really is no problem.
Lists also slow you down by at least a factor of two.
Also have you ever considered how strange it is that we advocate the use of lists on the ground (when there is no pressure or difficulty) yet always refer to memory when airborne (when you are under a considerablely higher workload)?
A final point I would add...............if you do use lists............then USE THEM ALL THE TIME!
Happy landings
JWF
