ex-RAF truckie, now been in the UK civil industry for 14 years - 3 Airlines - and used the full gamut of charts, but now using Jeppy.
First of all, pilots like what they know and you have to bear that in mind when reading/hearing pilots' comments. What do I think? Basically, the Jepps have the most information on their App Charts, but even after 6 years I sometimes find it hard to find it ie they are cluttered. Eg the little round 'ballnotes' - it is sometimes hard to find the decode. Why is the descent slope info in %? Why are they not in colour - I gather this is coming? Not always info on DATIS of the ACARS variety.
Aerad - or whatever they are called this week - seem much clearer and better laid out. Try finding your way around CDG on the Jepp plates - and the paper is so thin that it quickly deteriorates/tears.
These are just a few of my views which I do not expect everyone to agree with - but you did ask!
Regards
mcdhu