Looks like Verbatim seem to be OK, cant see much bad on the net, even though they are not really rated anywhere.
So its Verbatim 1.5 esata vs Samsung sata and enclosure, both coming to the same price.
The Verbatim is a 7200rpm vs samsung at 5200rpm, both 32mb cache, both USB2 for my purpose, the Verbatim has eSATA, but doubt i will be using that with no esata port or a clue what one is.