Looks like discussion on this issue is like discussion on jetstar being subsidised by mainline - impossible to have a rational argument.
Direct anywhere - The fleet managers said that last year also, then suddenyl we were all on leave and flexi lines to save 9m which was promptly given to Dixon to sort out his tax.
RENUP - I know why a lot of these guys are still flying because I used to fly with them when I was an F/O.
Many of them used to boast about "dying in the seat" before giving up their place to a junior pilot.....