As I see it, the point is that the flight deck automation has gone way too far,
we need to 'back off' somewhat, AND reintroduce the PFE, that's my point AND that of many others here and elsewhere!
In my humble opinion I think you are both correct. Automation is a great thing and has made planes safer in an ever busier environment. Unfortunately the PFE was a casualty in this process, mostly to save money. I would think it would be great to have the PFE back in conjunction with the modern automation. I feel with these new giant planes, flying thousands of miles and with new security concerns it is the responsible thing to do. If this were the case the modern PFE would be more of a computer geek. And the Captain would have more time to manage the aircraft. Kinda of like Captain Kirk.....
And if this were to happen some of you old geezers could help as consultants and trainers. Maybe that's the idea all along
