PJ2,
Agree wholeheartedly! My earlier comment to close the thread was not meant in any way to be a slight on you or any of your fellow professionals who had concurred that in this particular case the pilot(s) had performed in an exemplary manner. The intention was to encourage PTH that the concensus was so overwhelming, that he could achieve nothing but damage his credibility, from equally knowledgeable and experienced peers on this forum.
I have enjoyed the absorbing technical insight given by notables such as yourself justme69, Rainboe, NoD, Vailpilot(?) and number more whose names escape me at the moment, into some of the saddest and miraculous outcomes experienced by crew and passengers alike. So long may it continue!
Cheers
sAx