bast0n,
I am genuinely not wishing to sound offensive here but I have never really got my head around where you are trying to come from, I know I am but a simple soul but I am as flummoxed now as I ever was
Like you I suspect the guys quite probably got it horribly wrong on the day but where we depart is that I accept that "I suspect" simply does not cut the mustard with regards to the verdict.
Without clear, concise and fully substantiated evidence how can anyone possibly KNOW exactly what happened that day.
If we do not know EXACTLY what happened we can all surmise till the cows come home, and you and I seem to have a similar mindset, but surely in that case the only possible VERDICT is CNPD and not what the two AM's surmised.