I think that almost everyone would agree that Air Nelson IS a better job than Eagle for various reasons, however that does not mean that Eagle is a bad job. There is always somewhere better isn't there.
At Eagle you get paid quite good money (for what you do) and get pretty good terms and condtions to boot. I think that given todays enviroment where things have slowed down a lot, especially those trying to get out of GA, you'd have to be very brave or very patient to not go for Eagle given that they are pretty short staffed right now and surely some interviews are just round the corner, when the crew levels at Air Nelson are still pretty good, and they may potentially not higher for quite some time.
Each to their own though, everyone has different circumstances.