Yes Steve, thank you very much for stating the obvious! Those are the basics I was suggesting we should stick to. Whatever is done, it has to be consistent across the board. A lot less subjectivity and a lot more objectivity. They seem unable to acheive any level of consistency throughout the training or checking system. As the yanks say, It's like a box of chocolates... you never know what you're going to get! Too many personal preferrences are thaught as absolutes and too many wild ideas among those preferrences to make matters worse. Simlify, make consistant, put it in writing.
And for ****'s sake if you're going to continue to have this writeup system and in fact expand it, provide a serious essay writing class for these chaps so when it all comes out in public during a lawsuit (sooner or later), it's not so embarressing to read the 3rd grade level writing some of these chaps muster!