Remove the word "hypothetically" and how does it read?
I think I have said more than I should have already, so I will bow out safe in the knowledge I did as much as I could to defend the professionalism of the Captain in question.
As is always the case, some see red where blue is presented, and there is obviously nothing more I can do for those of you who need more. The issue is still "under investigation" and, as such, I should probably not have put as much in public as I have. However, this forum has a tendency to undermine pilots and, in this instance, and because I doubt he reads this forum, I felt I needed to defend his honor.
Believe what you will. I know the truth and believe we should all hold our opinions, especially when they undermine us all, until further is known. I have given as much (more!) as I can.
My best to you all.