omg REPA
Do BLAPA have a sausage machine where diehards are turned out spouting the same things company to company.
I am hearing your words or similar from every company that rejects BALPA.
Cant you for once Give in Gracefully and bide your time for a couple more years, by which time the market will have changed again, and you might have a better chance at success. (As long as you exclude BRK the answer will be NOT)
Remember they (RYR pilots) have as much right to their diverse opinions as you do to yours.
But by now I am sure they are fed up of listening to this twaddle from both sides.
Get on with the job in hand, go out and fly the aeroplanes in the most professional manner possible, and let this argument rest.