Some really good points made, and I hope that maybe DEC ALM and JHC maybe consider some of them (if they haven't already done so, which I suspect is the case).
The key decision remains - what does JHC want to look like in the future, as it has the real opportunity to right the wrongs for today, and position itself for the future.
If we all agree that if the Puma LEP is a wise move and that the Commando Sea King fleet should be the first to be re-roled, then the powers that be need to make a decision on how it wants to deliver its amphibious lift capability, as well as supporting current land operations.
Although I admit I have a vested interest in leaving CHF as an autonomous (under JHC - but dedicated to 3 Cdo Bde), organic (lift and strike) capability because I really am one of those light blue that hate the O Boat. But also I do recognise that the maritime environment does require specialist skills, knowledge and experience. I also like the idea of CHF supporting 3 Cdo Bde on land operations that would potentially give our SHF and the Army AH a rest.
Sadly I believe that the AH and to a certain degree the CH47 fleet are not that bit interested in maintaining a true amphibious capability, and probably in the AH case would have to start from scratch every time it wanted to embark as the whole double earmarking concept has just not worked.
Before any talk of re-roling the Commando Sea Kings and CHF can take place, someone has to make that much awaited, much delayed, but vitally important decision on how JHC wants to deliver its amphibious capability, as well as continue to support and improve the lift to current operations.