PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF447
Thread: AF447
View Single Post
Old 2nd July 2009 | 16:21
  #2694 (permalink)  
HarryMann
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 760
Likes: 9
From: Herts, UK
One of my ground school instructors had been accident investigator in the USAF. He said victims of a flat spin were intact in their seats, just dead.
A gross appproximation maybe! The tell-tale would be as in the LHR Staines accident, yes 'likely' to be still strapped in, but with compressed verterbae almost uniformly.

Look, there's a whole host of people here, maybe pilots maybe not, but this is engineering and kinematics stuff, or a lot of it is... accident investigation - certainly impact dynamics is NOT necessarily just about flying and piloting knowledge, unless so many have had a lot of accidents & walked away... there's opinions flying about like wasps in a jam-jar here, and that's all most of them are, 6 possibilities back ther in ONE post!!

We need to take deep breath... and let some experts think this through a bit.

====

For what it is worth, 'high acceleration' an engineer usually means in this context... a/c arrived with large deceleration upon impact e.g. it was travelling fast & stopped very quickly.

High acceleration is just they way it is said... inplying large forces.

I also interpret the previous line to mean the trajectory was predominantly vertical but the attitude was predominantly horizonatal (line of normal flight)

In fact much as takata said...
HarryMann is offline