Captain J*** L***** and Terry - if you want to have a playground fight feel free to do so, just don't do it in my effing inbox
I get the same emails as you: where should the issue be ventilated? Here, or in house?
Strikes me that the responses have been quite subdued when you consider that the BALPA email was quite scurrilous.
You behave like a nimby: let everyone else do the work and you'll take the benefit. If you don't want BALPA vote against it, you have the email address like the rest of us. Don't just mouth off about it here.