OK, Dani, I'll bite one more time. Yes, you have a theoretical point - you are probably right that there is a very good chance of getting back to the departure end of your runway in ideal circumstances. It is the stark presentation of your 'theory' that has caused all the turmoil here. Statements like the 'second best choice', 'they could have made it back', 'not the best choice' and so on.
I think you should make a big effort to meet the good Captain. Ask him what went through his mind when he came around the corner and (luckily) had a good view of the metropolis spread out around all the option airfields.
Perhaps, as you have done now, if you had tempered your initial post considerably the reaction may have been better.